BOARD OF HISTORIC AND ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
MINUTES
May 11, 2009
Council Chambers, Plaza Level, Government Center
3:30 p.m.
A meeting of the Board of Historic and Architectural Review was held on Monday,
May 11, 2009, at 3:30 p.m., 100 10th Street, Government Center, Council
Chambers.
Members Present:
Sia Etemadi Will Burgin
Jeff Reed Virginia Peebles
Reynolds Bickerstaff Eva Smith
Stacy Fahrenbruch Elizabeth Barker
Members Absent:
John Sheftall Charles Donald Beall
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Will Burgin called the meeting to order at 3:40 p.m.
II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Chairman Will Burgin asked for a motion on the minutes for the April 13, 2009
meeting. Virginia Peebles made a motion to approve the minutes. Reynolds
Bickerstaff seconded the motion. Motion was carried unanimously.
Chairman Will Burgin asked that the Staff Report are read and approved as part
of the BHAR meeting. Reynolds Bickerstaff made a motion to approve the Staff
Report. ___________ seconded the motion. The motion carried unanimously.
III. REVIEW OF APPLICATIONS
NEW CASES:
HD 0905-01 ? 1828 Overlook Street: Richard A. Munn, Jr., Applicant. Request
permission to construct carport / storage addition. Board Member Sia Etemadi
excused himself from voting. Chairman Will Burgin read Staff Report for case.
Sia Etemadi stated that applicant would like storm windows added to
application. Will Burgin stated that windows would need to be a separate
application with a staff approval. After a brief discussion, Virginia Peebles
made a motion to approve the application. ________ seconded the motion. The
motion was carried unanimously.
HD 0905-02 ? 627 Broadway: Cathy & Chuck Williams, Applicants. Request
permission to replace plaster treatment on front fa?ade, replace siding with
fiber cement cedar lap siding and replace windows with same and architectural
shingles with same. Will Burgin read the criteria from the Staff Report.
Applicant Cathy Williams stated that side and back windows would be replaced
with true divided light wood windows. Applicant also discussed the type of
siding that they want to use. Historic Columbus Foundation will have a fa?ade
easement on the house. After a lengthy discussion, Reynolds Bickerstaff made a
motion to approve the application with the following conditions:
Documentation of existing materials and deterioration.
Applicant approved to use smooth hardi-plank siding on the north, south and
back sides.
Reclaim brick on foundation.
Original fa?ade restored to replicate original stone.
Wood replacement windows of same size and original openings.
Architectural shingles to replace same.
Virginia Peebles seconded the motion. By a show of hands the vote was 5-1 to
approve the application with the condition. Sia Etemadi opposed the approved
application.
IV. OLD BUSINESS
Lynda Temples reminded everyone about the Public Meeting concerning the Update
to the Design Guidelines following the BHAR meeting at 5:30.
V. ADJOURNMENT
4:39 P.M.
Respectfully Submitted By:
____________________________________
Will Burgin, Chairman
___________________________________
Lynda Temples, Secretary
Attachments
No attachments for this document.