Columbus, Georgia
Georgia's First Consolidated Government
Post Office Box 1340
Columbus, Georgia, 31902-1340
(706) 653-4013
fax (706) 653-4016
Council Members
MINUTES
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
EMPLOYEES' PENSION PLAN
May 7, 2003
A meeting of the Board of Trustees for the Columbus Georgia Employees= Pension
Plan was held May 7, 2003 at 2:00 P.M. in the Mayor=s Conference Room.
PRESIDING: Mr. Daniel Gray, Vice-Chairman
PRESENT: Kay G. Love, Mary Strozier-Weaver, Alan Rothschild, and Capt.
John Starkey
ABSENT: Mayor Bob Poydasheff, Carmen Cavezza, Morton Harris, Jack Nowell,
Saundra Hunter and Michael Majure
GUESTS: Henry Swift, Vice President (Salomon Smith Barney) and Denise Baxter,
Investment Officer (CCG)
Mr. Daniel Gray, Vice-Chairman called the meeting to order. Julia Rasch,
Recording Secretary, gave the attendance. It was noted that the Mayor was out
of the country and the other Trustees who were absent had conflicting
appointments with the exception of Mr. Michael Majure. The Board was advised
that Mr. Majure has accepted an appointment with the State Of Georgia and will
not be returning as a Trustee to the Pension Fund.
MINUTES OF THE PREVIOUS MEETING:
The motion was made by Ms. Strozier-Weaver and seconded by Capt. Starkey that
the minutes from the April 2, 2003 meeting be accepted as submitted. The vote
was unanimous.
INVESTMENT UPDATE:
Mr. Swift began his report by stating that he didn?t want to spend a lot of
time on the quarterly report ending March 2003 but more on what has happened
since the end of the quarter. The highlights of the quarter indicate that with
the fixed income managers shortening their maturities schedule in anticipation
of rates going up later this year, their performance was impacted. They all
three fell slightly behind the index for the quarter. Mr. Swift doesn?t feel
that it?s a material shortfall but anticipates that if rates turn up that they
will all do considerably better.
Most of the equity managers with the exception of Trusco Capital and Lazard
were behind their index slightly for the quarter, but not any of them to any
material degree. Concern with the performance of the equity managers continue,
specifically with Victory Capital, but for the most part, most of the equity
managers were fairly close to the benchmark. So the equity part of the
portfolio is sort of a mixed bag with certain managers doing better than others
but none of them doing very poorly with the possible exception of Victory.
Over all, the equity managers were down for the quarter, ?3.5% versus ?3.6%,
for the blended benchmark. And since inception, the equity managers were up
8.0% versus 8.4%, so they?re right on the benchmark and ahead of the benchmark
for the one, three and five year periods.
The total fund for the quarter was down ?1.2% versus -.83% for the index.
Since inception the total fund is up 8% versus 8.1% for the index. This is a
number that the board should be proud of given the fact that the S&P was down
three years in a row, 2000, 2001 and 2002 and rather dramatically too, 21%, 13%
and 24% respectively.
Mr. Swift concluded the quarterly report by asking if there were any questions
before he continued with what has happened since the quarter ended. He also
stated that this report should be accepted and entered into the minutes as
reported.
The next part of Mr. Swift?s report summarized what has happened since the
board?s last meeting. Using the graphs he began with the S&P 500 index which
showed a 9.2% rise in a 36 day period; on April 1st the market was at 858.43
and rose to 937.03 by May 7th. Mr. Swift pointed out that it was right around
March 12th that the oil fields in Iraq were secured which indicates that the
investing public was not so much concerned about whether the U.S. could win the
war but whether or not the oil fields could be secured without tremendous loss
of all reserves and therefore pushing oil prices higher.
The next chart showed the bond market over the same period of time. The bond
market over the last 30 days fluctuated tremendously, the bond yield went from
4.61% on March 12th to a high of 4.99% on April 7th and then falling back to
4.71% on May 7th with a net result of staying pretty much in the same position.
The next report was the valuation recap. The bond managers had a slight pickup
in their overall value over the last 30 days with a little more than ? to 1%
return giving a balance of $70 million dollars in bonds. The growth managers
had a very strong 30-day period. Eagle Asset, the newest manager, up 9.5%;
Rittenhouse up almost 8%, combined, they were up a little over 8%. Of the
value managers, Scudder had the best performance of all, up 11%; Victory also
had a nice recovery, up 8.5%. The total combined value was up 10.03%. Trusco
Capital and National Asset, the Core managers were both up for the last month.
National Asset?s performance was better than Trusco, but then Trusco had done
much better for the quarter ending March 30th. Combined, the core managers
were up over 7% for the period. Lazard, the international manager was up
11.61%.
The end result is, taking all the equities on an absolute basis, not time
weighted; they were up almost 9% which is pretty much tracking the S&P 500.
The total fund is up almost $7 million dollars in 30 days and that is a
tremendous increase.
Finally, Mr. Swift went over the reallocation and withdrawal report and gave a
brief recap. To summarize; $7,450,000 dollars was taken away from the fixed
and value managers and redistributed to the various equity managers plus
$1,700,000 was disbursed to the city to pay retiree benefits. The reallocation
took place in January, February and March and with the market moving as it did
a reallocation in April was not necessary because the equities took off just as
the reallocation was completed which worked out in favor of the pension fund.
There was a few minutes discussion between Mr. Swift and Mr. Gray about what
the market may or may not do in the next few months. The consensus was that it
was impossible to predict that outcome of the market but Mr. Swift did indicate
that he didn?t feel the market growth would continue at the rate of the current
increase.
A copy of the evaluation report and the other reports are maintained by the
Board Secretary in the Finance Director=s Office and is available for review
upon request.
PRESENTATION:
Mr. Frank Sposato from Lazard International was the guest speaker for today?s
board meeting.
& International Equity Management
P Team-based decision-making
P Internally-generated research
P Proprietary quantitative tools and models
P Disciplined risk management
& Investment Process
P Analytical Framework
P Accounting Validation
P Fundamental Analysis
P Portfolio Construction
& Market Performance
P A performance comparison of the markets in The Americas, Europe and
Far East vs. the U.S for the Year To Date December 31, 2002 and March 31, 2003.
& Performance Review
P Total portfolio performance summary through April 30, 2003 including
the total portfolio composition.
P Portfolio Characteristics vs. MSCI EAFE Index
P What Helped/What Hurt Performance
P Region/Sector Exposure vs. MSCI EAFE
P The Market?s Volatility and it?s effects
P Portfolio holdings by country and by sector
% Market Outlook
P 3 Year Outlook
P Risks
P EAFE vs. U.S. - Returns Have Come Full Circle
Mr. Sposato concluded his report. He was thanked by the board and dismissed as
the meeting resumed.
OLD BUSINESS:
None
NEW BUSINESS:
None
With no further business for discussion, the motion was made by Mr. Rothschild
and seconded by Ms. Strozier-Weaver that the meeting be adjourned. The next
meeting is scheduled for June 4, 2003 at 2:00 p.m. in the Mayor=s Conference
Room. The guest speaker will be from Trusco Capital (Core) and Synovus
Securities (Fixed Income).
_____________________________
Julia A. Rasch
Recording Secretary