Columbus, Georgia
Georgia's First Consolidated Government
Post Office Box 1340
Columbus, Georgia, 31902-1340
(706) 653-4013
fax (706) 653-4016
Council Members
MINUTES OF THE
Pension Board Meeting
October 1, 2003
BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETING OF THE
COLUMBUS GEORGIA EMPLOYEES' PENSION PLAN
October 1, 2003
A meeting of the Board of Trustees for the Columbus Georgia Employees= Pension
Plan was held October 1, 2003 at 2:00 P.M. in the Mayor=s Conference Room.
PRESIDING: Mayor Robert Poydasheff, Chairman
PRESENT: Morton Harris, Daniel Gray, Harvey Milner, Jack Nowell, Mary
Strozier-Weaver, Alan Rothschild, Captain John Starkey
ABSENT: Carmen Cavezza, Kay G. Love, Joe Smith
GUESTS: Henry Swift, Vice President (Salomon Smith Barney), Richard Swift,
(Salomon Smith Barney), Denise Baxter, Investment Officer (CCG),
Mayor Robert Poydasheff, Chairman called the meeting to order. Kay Love on
behalf of Julia Rasch, Recording Secretary, gave the attendance. Mayor
Poydasheff stated that the roll call could be dispensed with and the attendance
sheet be passed among the attendees for them to initial their presence.
MINUTES OF THE PREVIOUS MEETING:
The motion was made by Mr. Morton Harris and seconded by Harvey Milner that the
minutes from the September 10, 2003 meeting be accepted as submitted. The vote
was unanimous.
INVESTMENT UPDATE:
Mr. Henry Swift introduced Mr. Richard Swift, his son, and stated that he would
be attending the pension board meetings going forward. He handed out
information that included charts on the stock and bond markets and the
portfolio valuation as of August 5, 2003.
The interim report that was presented covered the last 21 days, from the last
meeting on September 9, 2003 to the current meeting. This report is early in
the cycle, therefore, does not cover a very extended period of time, but at the
November meeting a full performance evaluation for the quarter will be
presented.
The first chart, which reflects the equity market as measured by the S&P 500
indicates a drop of about 3.5% over this last three-week period.
The next page shows the 30-year Treasury Bond. In the middle of June yields
started to go back up because prices were coming down and the fixed income
managers suffered through that, but since about the first of August, the 30
year Treasury Yield topped out at about 5.5% and since that time it has been
coming back down. In fact, as of close on 09/09/03 it stood at 4.88%. So what
has happened in the stock market is the fund has given up a little ground but
made a little back in the bond market. Unfortunately not enough in the bond
market to offset what has happened in equities, but nevertheless a little bit
of a cushion.
Mr. Harris inquired as to how the fixed income managers were handling things
with the trend going down.
Mr. Swift stated that he felt they were being very, very careful. He feels
they?re very concerned about whether the move down in rates will continue, but
that if there should be another move up, then the prices in the bond market
would be obviously be negatively affected.
The next page takes you through the usual format that is used to look at the
managers. All three of the fixed income managers were ahead for the last three
weeks. First Union had the best performance of all three, they were ahead
almost 1.7%. All three had a positive period during this short time for a
total combined fixed account up 1.1%. Both growth managers were down, Eagle
actually had the worst performance of all the money managers, down 4%.
Rittenhouse was down 2%. Normally these kinds of returns are not seen over a
year or a quarter much less a 21-day period and really speaks to the volatility
of the stock market. The combined growth managers were down 2.7%. The
combined value managers were down 2.8%. Victory Capital will present today and
the board should keep in mind they have been on our watch list. They met with
the committee about three or four months ago to discuss their performance
status. If, they don?t address this issue today, the board should ask them to
because their results certainly have been sub-par. Core managers, Trusco and
National Assets are both down about 3.5%. The combined core down 3.4%
As for the international manager, Lazard Asset, a combination of both the large
and small cap fund values were down less than 40 basis points. The combined
equities as would be expected with the market being down, were down 2.7% and
the value of the account dropped from $158.3 million to $156.7 million. It
appears that stocks have not done well and bonds have done pretty good.
Mr. Harris asked Mr. Swift what was the total amount of the fund 1 to 3 yeas
ago. Mr. Swift stated that it was up to about $178 million and indicated that
the fund took a pretty good hit with the bear market.
He stated that going back to February 2000, when the market peaked and then
started down in March and the NASDAQ followed, it peaked in about the middle of
May 2000 and through March of 2003, equities had a significant downfall.
Having kept 50/55% of the money in bonds and with the bond market?s huge rally
in the last two years. The fund has earned 10-11% a year on the bonds, which
has been huge buffer.
A copy of the evaluation report and the other reports are maintained by the
Board Secretary in the Finance Director=s Office and is available for review
upon request.
PRESENTATION:
Henry introduced the Conrad Metz, Senior Portfolio Manager, and Frank Felice,
Senior Client Manager from Victory Capital Management, who were here to present
their annual report. Mr. Metz introduced Robb Bunnen as an institutional sales
representative with Victory Capital Management. He has been with Victory for
over ten years and has the Southeast territory, was in town visiting and wanted
to meet the board.
The report followed the Agenda listed below:
Investment Policy Guidelines
Style:
They invest in value-oriented investments, in companies, whose stocks offer
above average total return potential compared to the Russell 1000 Value Index.
Objective:
The portfolio objective is to display a level of risk associated with the
portfolio, which is less that the risk associated with Russell 1000 Value
Index. And, is expected to generate a total return that equals or exceeds the
Russell 1000 Value index.
Market Review
Investment Highlights
Portfolio Allocation
Portfolio Performance
Dispersion Of Returns
Sector Weights
Top 10 Holdings
Portfolio Characteristics
Economic And Equity Outlook
The stock market?s second quarter rally is running ahead and, hopefully,
leading way. The U.S. economy is well positioned for above-average growth
Invest Process
The Sector teams make outstanding selection decisions
The Buy and Sell Disciplines
Supplemental Information
Asset Statement
List of the stocks ordered by attribute as well as new stocks that went into
the portfolio or positions that were closed.
Mr. Metz and Mr. Felice were thanked for the presentation and with no further
questions, they were dismissed from the meeting.
Mr. Harris asked Mr. Swift what he thought about Victory since they are on our
watch list.
Mr. Swift responded by stating that basically what they?re saying is that the
market is going to come to them, that it?s going to start favoring their style
of investments. He reconfirmed that even though in the last quarter they were
flat with the Russell 1000, they are still 800 basis points behind and that is
the most he has seen from any manager. He feels they should be kept on the
watch list and that the board start looking at the next couple of quarters and
if the gap doesn?t narrow then the board needs to review them again.
Mayor Poydasheff asked if the board should send them a letter informing them
that they will continue to be on the watch list?
Mr. Harris stated that a letter to that effect, that the board appreciates
their fine report and that they are certainly doing better, but that they will
continue to be on the watch list and hope that things get better soon.
OLD BUSINESS:
None
NEW BUSINESS:
None
With no further business for discussion, Mr. Gray tendered the motion to
adjourn and being seconded by Capt. Starkey the meeting was adjourned.
The next meeting is scheduled for November 5, 2003 at 2:00 p.m. in the Mayor=s
Conference Room. The guest speaker will be from Evergreen Investments.
_____________________________
Julia A. Rasch
Recording Secretary