Columbus, Georgia
Georgia's First Consolidated Government
Post Office Box 1340
Columbus, Georgia, 31902-1340
(706) 653-4013
fax (706) 653-4016
Council Members
MINUTES OF THE
BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETING OF THE
COLUMBUS GEORGIA EMPLOYEES' PENSION PLAN
July 14, 2004
A meeting of the Board of Trustees for the Columbus Georgia Employees? Pension
Plan was held July 14, 2004 at 2:00 P.M. in the Mayor?s Conference Room.
PRESIDING: Mayor Robert Poydasheff, Chairman
PRESENT: Angela Cole, Morton Harris, Jack Nowell, Mary Strozier-Weaver, Dan
Gray, and Joe Smith
ABSENT: Carmen Cavezza, Alan Rothschild, Jr., Harvey Milner, and Capt John
Starkey
GUESTS: Henry Swift, Vice President (Salomon Smith Barney), Richard Swift,
(Salomon Smith Barney), Gwen Marsh (Columbus Water Works), Denise Baxter
(Revenue Division), April Harris (Financial Planning Division)
Mayor Bob Poydasheff, called the meeting to order. Julia Rasch, Recording
Secretary, gave the attendance.
MINUTES OF THE PREVIOUS MEETING:
A motion to accept the minutes from the May 5, 2004 meeting and the June 2,
2004 conference call meeting was made and the vote to accept was unanimous.
INVESTMENT UPDATE:
Mr. Swift addressed the board with a recap of what has happened in the market
for the period from 5/31/2004 through close of business on 7/13/04. In the
last 30 days, rates have come down as bond prices have gone up at about the
same rate.
The three fixed income managers had a positive 30-day period; they were up
about ? of 1% over this past six weeks. Synovus who will be presenting today
was up 43 basis points.
The growth managers were down collectively about -1.74% during this period of
time. Eagle Asset, who the committee just had a meeting with for two hours,
was down almost -4%.
The value managers, Deutsche Asset and Victory both were up a little, 0.38%.
The core managers were down with Trusco being down -2.25%.
The international manager, Lazard was up 1.50%, which was good over this short
period of time. The international portfolio is up to 10 million dollars. A
meeting with Lazard needs to be set at some point to discuss with them the
issue of moving the large cap portion from a mutual fund status to a managed
fund status. The Mayor suggested that it be discussed at the August meeting.
The combined equities were up .61%. The total city account went from 166
million dollars to 165.9 million dollars, so for all practical purposes during
this six-week period the portfolio did absolutely nothing. The portfolio did
not make any progress but at the same time did not lose anything.
Mr. Swift informed the board that Fred Gaskin with Deutsche Asset has accepted
a position with another firm. Mr. Tom Sassi, the senior portfolio manager,
will continue to make the investment decisions and be responsible for our
portfolio. He thinks the board should consider asking Mr. Sassi to come down
to meet with the board regarding the investment process.
Mr. Swift will try to bring Mr. Sassi in for the August meeting, but if he is
not available he will try to set a meeting in September. He assured the board
that he did not feel there was anything to be concerned about because Mr. Sassi
has been overseeing the portfolio for a long time and that he is the one that
hired Mr. Gaskin.
A copy of the evaluation reports and the other information presented to the
board is retained by the Board Secretary in the Finance Director=s Office and
is available for review upon request.
PRESENTATION:
Mr. Swift introduced Mr. Len Sexton and Mr. Jeffrey Smith of Synovus to present
their annual report at today?s meeting.
The report followed the Agenda listed below:
Current Economic Conditions/Market Summary
Selected Economic Indicators
ISM Manufacturing Index
Nonfarm Employment
Portfolio Analysis & Performance Summary
Principal Volatility as it Relat4es to Portfolio Duration
Rising Bond Rates
Interest Rate Forecast
Portfolio Performance Review
Distribution Of Assets
June 30, 2002 ? June 30, 2004
Composition
Maturity Schedule
Synovus Securities Overview & Advisory Team
Mr. Sexton and Mr. Smith both were thanked for their presentation and with no
further questions, were dismissed from the meeting.
OLD BUSINESS:
Mr. Swift reported that the committee had met on two issues. The first issue
was to study the request from Lazard Asset to convert large cap stocks from a
Mutual Fund status to a Managed Fund status. The committee should be ready to
come back to the board in August with their recommendation. The second issue
was to meet with Eagle Asset Management on their performance, which has been
well behind the index. He asked that the three of them report on that meeting
to the rest of the board.
Mr. Smith, Mr. Harris and Mr. Gray were all in agreement that their methodology
and style of picking stocks was in question. They are also concerned about the
consistency of their performance which has been far below the index and that
the volatility of the returns compared to the index seems to be more extreme
than other managers.
Mr. Harris made a motion that the board place them on a continuous watch and
that they be evaluated again in not more than a year.
The vote was unanimous.
NEW BUSINESS:
None
With no further business for discussion, the motion was tendered for
adjournment.
The next meeting is scheduled for August 4, 2004 at 2:00 p.m. in the Mayor=s
Conference Room. Eagle Asset and National Asset will be here for their annual
report.
_____________________________
Julia A. Rasch
Recording Secretary